(I will be using the 4 star system for my review, as in everything is rated out of 4 rather than the 5 you might be used to…. just a heads up)
If ever a director could be described as an auteur with their own distinct style, Wes Anderson would be right up there as someone deserving of that title. Asteroid City is potentially Anderson leaning into his “isms” more than any of his previous films. At first it comes across as overly self-indulgent, confusing and at times even a little off-putting, but the more you sit with what he’s really trying to say, the more you realise this is actually Anderson at his most introspective and the film where he potentially has the most to say about the creative process. Anderson want’s our imaginations to run wild, for us to dream whatever dream we can, but before we do that we have to allow ourselves to delve into that headspace. As his cast chants; “You can’t wake up if you don’t fall asleep.”
Asteroid City is a meta-tale, following the story of a TV show telling the story of a play that tells the story of extra-terrestrial events reeking havoc on the itinerary of a 1995 Junior Stargazing competition, all whilst the families of the candidates and the small number of residents of the titular town reckon with what all of it means in the context of their own lives, problems and situations.
Yes, that is quite the plot summary, but it hopefully accurately depicts the “story upon a story” nature of the way Anderson has chosen to tell this narrative. It’s both the film’s greatest strength and it’s greatest weakness. Initially it is quite arresting. You’re expecting the usual colours and vibrancy to hit you in the face from the get go but instead we’re transported to a black and white screen and a rather dapper looking Bryan Cranston telling us this isn’t the story we might have been expecting. Therefore the issue the film has to wrestle with is that it is almost instantly quite complex, knowing where we are in the story can then be quite difficult to follow and becomes a little frustrating. As we bounce between different layers of the story, keeping track of each tale and which character is truly which becomes more laboured than it needs to be. Anderson is enjoying himself but it would be fair to acknowledge that any criticisms of this being one of his most self-indulgent films are hard to argue against. Fortunately, Anderson sticks the landing. It is understandable that this film really might not be for everyone but as we truck along to its conclusion, Anderson manages to tie in all the random notes and anecdotes into something genuinely affecting with something moving to say on the nature of creativity and how an actor truly understands the depth of the character they’re attempting to play. It’s certainly pretentious, yes, but sometimes a little pretention didn’t hurt anyone and can still lead us to some truly touching moments. The complex narrative and multi-layered, meta nature of the film definitely makes Asteroid City a less enjoyable experience at times but overall it serves to further the questions the film is asking about the nature of creativity in a way that will have you thinking long after you’ve left the cinema screen. Although maybe this review is starting to fall into Anderson levels of pretention too… Regardless, for the most part Anderson’s directorial and written work, alongside Roman Coppola, is a success and it’s still very good to see auteurs being allowed their space to create something truly different.
Any Wes Anderson film, however must also pay homage to his technical collaborators that help create the wacky worlds that pour out of his unusual imagination. This is another, expected, example of excellent production and set design. This is often the case with Anderson films, he loves to find ways to create obscure worlds and quirky places and Asteroid City, a small place built around a crater where an asteroid fell many years ago, is another spectacularly cooky town. Adam Stockhausen continues his wonderful collaboration with Anderson then, having been nominated for many awards for their previous work, it would be a strong snub if Stockhausen was not recognised again here. Colourful and vibrant, yet with every last detail set perfectly in to place, it’s a feast for the eyes, especially for anyone who enjoys symmetry and order. It would be fair to say this style is not for everyone but we can probably all agree that there feats in creating these worlds are still something to be marvelled at. Kris Moran’s set direction must also be given it’s fair dues for supporting this wider wonderful vision, especially as each level of the story feels distinct in it’s own right, whilst still maintaining the required style.
It’s also delightful to see Robert Yeoman continue his terrific cinematographic work with Anderson. These are two creatives who fully understand each other and Yeoman’s ability to work so wonderfully with all the classic Anderson shots is that of a true expert who has mastered their particular craft. There are lots of flashy dolly, tracking, panning shots as well as all the others we’d usually expect, but that shouldn’t discredit Yeoman from the work he does to support the melancholy that permeates so much of this movie. The lingering on the sad, defeated faces of the film’s stars, the empty space the camera allows us to spend a moment in, those are the true brilliant technical and yet moving works that Yeoman and Anderson have worked together on. It’s that underlying sadness and sense of feeling lost that really brings out the film’s most relatable aspects. Yes it’s fun to watch and very funny at times, but we even when they act like no human any of us know on the planet, we can still understand the pain surrounding many of those in the main roles, as well as some of the strong supporting performers. With Anderson you’ll always get a feast for the eyes, but he is at his most successful when he attempts to evoke emotion in your soul too.
If you know Anderson’s body of work, then you’ll know of his ability to obtain a large, talented cast and Asteroid City is no different. This could, however, be considered one of the best performances of one of his favourite collaborators, Jason Schwartzman. He’s often shown up in little moments recently, or we may be more aware of his comedic work but here he brings a leading presence that stands out. We see the pain of tragedy behind his eyes, even if they way he converses does little to show the true emotion boiling up beneath. Especially considering the dual nature of the character Schwartzman plays, we see honesty in both settings. Whether reckoning with how to play such a confusing character or allowing us glimpses of that character’s repressed sadness, evident in both is that these are both men trying to understand how to create and relate in a world that no longer makes sense or feels worth it. This is a performance to be cherished.
He’s not the only one providing such solid work either. Another particular standout is Scarlett Johansson. Her famous actress and yet mother of a genius character is feeling the same pain of Schwartzman’s; thus it is their scenes that most show the underlying sorrow running through this movie. She plays beautifully off of Schwartzman and you’ll yearn for their scenes. Margot Robbie does a similar job in her cameo and shows her ability command the screen if when her time on it is so short. That scene will stick with you. A lot of the usual characters provide the solid work you’d expect, Cranston and Norton in particular helping to also lead us through the many concurrent stories we’re watching. But the main supporting performance of note is one of the better recent turns of Tom Hanks. As an older, pained patriarch trying to understand how to deal with tragedy and support his grandchildren it’s not the showy performance we might expect, and yet we feel for him. It’s an excellent turn and another that will hopefully be noticed in his extensive cinematic lexicon.
Another real positive here is the performances of the younger characters. The genius, junior stargazers form a small friendship group. Initially strange, their willingness to hang out with people who finally understand them and some of their giving in to the same teenage angst as anyone else their age would, is a wonderful little series of vignettes in the wider wackier, partially intergalactic tale hurrying along in front of our eyes. It would be lovely to see some of these young actors continue to collaborate with an auteur their assured performances show they clearly understand.
Asteroid City may not be for everyone, it truly is Wes Anderson at some of his most Wes Anderson, but if you can get past the quirky and view the quiet melancholy and pain underneath you might just find yourself moved more than you would have expected. Yes the film can be confusing but it’s visually arresting and has some of Anderson and Yeoman’s must stunning frames put to screen. Close your eyes, fall asleep, dream, imagine, and wake up and experience something as frustrating at times as it is enjoyable.